Friday, August 25, 2006

Town Hall meeting September 6th re Homeland Security!

True North,

I have read with considerable interest the comments made in this forum as well as discussions I have had with elected officials and local citizenry from Cook County and Grand Marais. Please be advised that the U.S. Border Patrol will host an open town hall meeting on Wednesday, September 6, 2006 to discuss the new Border Patrol facility. Time and place will be announced on the local radio station and in the local newspapers. I look forward to meeting with you and please bring your questions. I will either answer them at the meeting or get answers to the questions I cannot answer at the time.

Regards to the Grand Marais Community.

Glen W. Schroeder
Chief Patrol Agent
Grand Forks Sector
701-775-6259

Thursday, August 24, 2006

Terrorist threat in Grand Marais?

Jailing “suspected terrorists” in Grand Marais
Dear True,
I am heartsick when I read of the Homeland Insecurity plan to invade Grand Marais. I imagine high barbed-wire fences, constant traffic from military trucks and helicopters, and political prisoners subject to the torture sanctioned by the Bushies. I dread the destruction of quietude and beauty in our tiny and unique harbor village. How many of us—residents, tourists and summer home folks—have expressed our dismay that our town will be destroyed by rampant developers? And yet no one ever thought about possible invasive destruction by the militant Bush administration and its Chertoff-cum-no-bid-crony-henchmen. Heedless of peace and goodness, these ambassadors of ill will want to spread their “evildoer” message where nobody is evil, and thereby INVITE attacks. No terrorist would ever have cared about Grand Marais until it became a conclave of prisons and jailers.
Help! Help! A day,” as dear Emily Dickinson said during the Civil War. What is so badly needed is overtures of peace. Let us rebuild Iraq and Lebanon, express our grief at the loss of civilian lives, and commit to building true peace with all of our billions now spent on war.
Jane Marple
“In a village I find that the worst gossip is so often true.”

Tuesday, August 22, 2006

How now, sacred cow?

Dear True,

How now? What does it all mean?

I read the message presented not as a parable, but as a fractured fairy tale. “We know what is best and if you will only do exactly what we want, we can all live happily ever after”. The real position of those who shovel this manure is: “it is not our plans to destroy the harbor and forever change the character of the town that are the cause of all the ill will and acrimony, it is the temerity of those that would oppose their betters - that is the real issue. It is those folks who like Grand Marais more than they like money that are the problem.” Since when is it a virtue to substitute personal greed for common sense and the right to hold and express an opinion?

In the real Grand Marais the imperative is not for those who oppose unbridled development to give in and do whatever it takes to get along, it is for everyone to act as responsible citizens in the best interest of the community’s present and future. That means civil discourse, but it also means to deal with facts and to do so in the open and to have a goal of a better Grand Marais, not a goal of the enrichment of a few at the expense of the future of the city.

The tale of the sacred cow is wholly bull. As for the issues at hand, the “large” pen, the “poor” planning, and the “unbridled” development can and should be stopped. And, our grandchildren will be very happy.

John Haluska
Grand Marais

Cow Hockey Parable

Dear True,

I'm still confused: is the Sacred Cow the town? or the harbor? or both? Mr. Shinners has composed a piece of cow hockey. I've taken my printout and numbered all the paragraphs so we can more clearly discuss it.

In paragraph #2 Shinners says people want to see the cow by boat. They can already come by boat. And what do they bring to the cow? They spend their money on liquor and food. No one is busy buying stuff to furnish their boat or stuff to mail home to furnish their homes. No one is staying in the motels because they can live on their boats. So it's a fallacy to say the boaters are increasing revenues in the town. The truth is: retail is hurting. Gasoline prices are keeping people from making the long drive to Grand Marais, and once they get here, they're hanging on to their pennies so they can afford the gasoline to get home. East Bay is having trouble getting full occupancy. The proposed Harbour House isn't selling out. God only knows about the Cobblestone Cove.

In paragraph #2 Shinners says "some wanted to ride their 4 wheel vehicles to see this amazing animal." Bull. The motor-brained locals want to scoot around unbridled, risking their lives and adding to the chaos of tourist traffic. Fine. This'll work until the first one winds up as a hood ornament on a Monson truck.

In paragraph #3 he mentions that for many years issues like this were discussed and decisions were reached that everyone could live with. Again, bull. Sometimes the contentiousness was so rife that issues were simply tabled because no one could agree, or else The Good Ole Boys Club running the current City Council went ahead illegally and allowed the changes they wanted to go through. Either way, the citizenry has grown bitter because its opinions have not been respected, no matter how vocally or elegantly expressed.

In paragraph #4 he says "Someone suggested that the cow be sold and the money used to save the town." Is this a reference to the illegal construction of the Cobblestone Condos and the razing of the Sea Wall? Have these two transactions saved the town? Not that I can see. The first appears like a carbuncle on the face of the harbor and the second appears stalled out.

In paragraph #4 he goes on to say "People became convinced of the righteousness of their cause to the exclusion of any compromise." Oh, yeah? Is he speaking from his own agenda? Or is he using that tired "argument by exadgeration" that if you don't agree with his views, you don't want any change whatsoever. The implication of this specious argument is that anyone who disagrees is foolish, that it's a black or white situation: you either want total change or you're small-minded. I, for one, am so tired of this old chestnut I could scream. Everyone with a brain in Grand Marais knows that change is inevitable and some changes are for the better, they just don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater. For instance, most people agree that the harbor could stand some updating and modification; they just don't think it needs to be totally filled with slips. Since we already know the boaters live on their boats and save their money for gasoline, food, and booze, their contribution to the revenues of the town are fairly minimal, but their annoyance factor is enormous because they clot the harbor, ruining its tranquil beauty and clear water with their noise, sewage, and oil slicks.

Also, in my day, I've known a large number of bullies who'd bandy the word "compromise" around like the white flag of truce when, in reality, their vision of compromise was "do it my way." They never compromised; they expected everyone else to conform and comply. I'm all for compromise provided it's really compromise and not coercion masquerading as compromise.

In paragraph #5, the people who lived in the town and have moved away are the ones who have made their personal financial killing and have moved on to greener (for them) pastures, leaving everyone else holding the bag. The former community spirit Jim Shinners seems to be pining for has been destroyed by the profiteers who gave no thought to the community or its citizens. It's been destroyed by city officials who circumvent the law to further their own private ends. It's being undermined by the massive influx of landsharks, profiteers, and speculators who've gathered here like vultures around a kill.

Lastly, in paragraph #6, he talks about how the "unbridled" development has been stopped and "the sacred cow preserved." If only! "Some of the people were very happy." Yes!

There is a way to preserve what is precious and still court progressive change. It involves common sense, a commodity sadly lacking in current community leadership. Rather than increasing the number of junk-filled tourist souvenir shops, we should take a lesson from the success of the North House School and increase the promotion of this town as a learning center. Grand Marais should become a mecca for those interested in nature, forgotten crafts, art, theatre and writing. It should become a kind of university town in a jewel-like setting, attracting students to its classes, tourists to its shows and performances. and residents as permanent faculty. The city should throw its weight behind these efforts. In addition, the small business park should do what it was designed to do, namely, be a SMALL business park rather than a huge government enclave that destroys the town with light pollution so that viewing the Northern Lights from your back yard becomes a thing of the past.

If Mr. Shinners and others of his ilk have the final say, our beloved Grand Marais is on the way to the abattoir.

A friend of Grand Marais

Sunday, August 20, 2006

Mulling the Homeland issue from many views in Grand Marais

Dear True,

Those who are concerned about the proposed development should take the opportunity described by Tom Resek to meet with Matt Geretschlaeger. Matt is forthright and honest and has the best interest of the community as a whole at heart. His position of working with developers often requires that he keeps information that he gets from them confidential. This is so the developer’s idea, which is essentially the developer’s intellectual property, is safeguarded out of fairness early on in the process to protect the developer in a competitive environment. There is a time and a place where all the information about a development and a developer can and should be made public. That place and time is not at the start of the process.

As for what is now known about the proposal for a Homeland Security facility, it is an idea worthy of serious consideration and probably deserves the full support of the community. While no one likes the leadership of the Homeland Security Department; or for that mater even the name of the department, the agencies under it are necessary parts of our government and a facility to house them is in order, and locating that facility in Cedar Grove Business Park in Grand Marais is a lot better than most other places in the county; if, for no other reason, in the business park, some influence and control can be exercised by the community, especially since it will be a private developer building and owning it rather than the federal government. If the federal government were the builder and owner it could be extremely difficult to influence either the process or the outcome.

That being said it is still important to approach this from fact, not emotion.

As presented so far the building is to primarily serve the border patrol’s needs. It will have indoor garage space for vehicles, office space for up to 50 people, a space for holding seized materiel, holding cells for prisoners, and outdoor space for parking and a for helicopter pad. All of these seem eminently reasonable and necessary and it is hard to see that objections to any one of them will be sustainable. The most problematic in terms of impact on the community is the helicopter pad where as most concerns so far relate to the size of the building and to the need for cells for prisoners. 34,000 square feet is large in the context of most structures in Grand Marais, but it is really not a very big building. It is the size of about 2 Walgreen drugstores, which are in the range of 16,000 to 19,000 feet, but have no indoor parking and don’t office 50 people.

The border patrol is a necessary part of our government and the work they do requires arrest and the detention of those arrested. The detainees have to be kept somewhere while they await transport or deportation. At present they are held in other facilities, some no doubt at the Cook County jail from time to time. What is wrong with housing them in this facility in Grand Marais? Nothing based on the information we have! Contrary to what some fear mongers have been saying, this is not a federal prison being proposed and it is not Guantanamo Bay.

What is wrong with adding a facility that will employ up to 50 people in fulltime, high wage by local standards jobs, with excellent benefits? That is not 50 prison guards, but 50 professionals whose wages we are already paying.

Those who work for the several agencies that come under Homeland Security are the Border Patrol, the Coast Guard, Immigration and Naturalization, FEMA, etc. While Homeland Security is a disaster at the top, these are essential units of our government, the people who work there are our friends and neighbors, and it is in our own best interest individually and as a community to find a way to accommodate this facility.

What is wrong with a local business that does not pollute?

What should the community’s concerns be?

There should be concern about openness. There needs to be an opportunity for a reasoned discussion. If it is to be accepted it cannot be jammed down our throats as if the DNR’s Let’s Build a Huge Marina Department and the present city administration would do. The public should have as much information about this facility as do the local officials. The EDA needs to respect the confidentiality of the developers, but it should not accept any suggestion of withholding any information based on security. Those concerned should make every effort and use every legal tool should to get as much information as possible into the public domain. The Minnesota Data Practices Act and the national Freedom of Information Act should be used as necessary to get information from all levels of government.

There also should be concern about process. The EDA under Matt Geretschlaeger has a reputation for integrity and in the community’s experience in dealing with Matt, that reputation is very well deserved. However, more information is need regarding whether or not the project was properly posted as an agenda item. If it wasn’t, the EDA needs to be taken to task with a complaint to the Department of Administration.

Unfortunately, the city is also involved, and the present administration’s reputation and history is the exact opposite of integrity. There have to be serious questions asked about conflicts of interest, openness of discussion and self-dealing on the part of officials. At present the mayor and others are reportedly under investigation by the Minnesota State Auditor for past actions. The planning commission, under Hal Greenwood, is shown to be pro development at any cost and has a reputation for favoritism. All of these points need to be factored in to dealing with this project and the public should insist on open and well publicized agendas and meetings, on written, rather than verbal documentation of discussion, communications, and actions, and on transparency regarding conflicts coupled with officials stepping away where any conflict exists.

Beyond that, there are serious questions regarding the location relative to residential development, particularly as it relates to the operation of a helicopter. They are a noisy nuisance and it can be expected that they would operate at all hours which would impact not only the proposed site, but the entire city.

The size of the proposed building is not too large, but something a bit bigger could be, though perhaps not in this type of facility. This project does, however, raise the question of what is too big for Grand Marais and Cook County. This should be taken as an opportunity for a community discussion on whether a Wal-Mart or Home Depot size big box retail operation is acceptable to the area? If the answer is no, that needs to be worked into local planning and zoning ordinances now.

What will the building look like and what do we want future buildings in the area – throughout the city and county – to look like? This is the time to have that discussion and incorporate some design values into local ordinances.

How will it impact adjacent residential areas and adjacent residential development plans? This needs to be understood and dealt with now, rather than after the project is built and helicopters buzz the city at 3 AM.

How many local, permanent jobs will result and who will get them?

There are likely just as many other questions that need to be answered, but the issue needs to be dealt with calmly and optimistically and the EDA is professionally run and has earned and deserves the community’s trust. The city, unfortunately, is a poster child for ineptitude and dishonesty. Trust the EDA, but verify. Do not trust the present city administration under any circumstances.

This rant is from a friend on the far left side of Grand Marais’ common sense divide.

The parable of the sacred cow

Dear True,

There was once a lakeside community of people who owned a wonderful cow. The cow could sing, dance, cure the sick, and do all sorts of unusual things. People came from all around to see the cow. People worked together, celebrated together, and enjoyed their community. No one locked their doors, and people in trouble could always turn to their neighbors.

This cow was kept in a special pen near the center of town and both the cow and the pen were cared for carefully. Economic pressures slowly began to overtake the town, as their infrastructure began to deteriorate and more and more people moved into the area to see the cow. One day someone suggested that people be allowed to come and see the cow by boat, so that more people could come and enjoy it. Others wondered if maybe some improvements to the pen or more and better lodging in the town wouldn’t make the cow more attractive. Some thought enabling people to travel by bicycle to see the cow would improve things. Some wanted to ride their 4 wheel vehicle to look at this amazing animal.

For many years issues like this were discussed by everyone in the community sitting down together and coming to a decision that all could agree to. This time however, some people said that they had come to this community because of the cow, and that no changes of any kind would be welcome. Others claimed that they had considered the issue and that only their solution would work. Finally someone said that anyone who disagreed with them was a fool and incompetent and that if they didn’t like their idea they should move away.

For the first time, people wouldn’t talk to their neighbors who disagreed with them. People were asked to take sides against those who had other ideas. Someone suggested that the cow be sold and the money used to save the town. People became convinced of the righteousness of their cause to the exclusion of any compromise. People had to remember who they disagreed with on which issue so they knew who they shouldn’t talk to. There was much discussion, arguing, and acrimony, both about the cow and toward people who didn’t agree.

Eventually, some young families left the community. Then some of the people who had been in the town for many years moved away. Many felt that the cow wasn’t worth all of the trouble it had brought to the town. Some of the businesses left and finally, doors were locked, and people didn’t speak to each other any more.

The “large” pen, the “poor” planning, and the “unbridled” development had been stopped. The sacred cow had been preserved. Some people were very happy.

Jim Shinners

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Homeland Security meeting with EDA Matt

I spoke to EDA Matt today, and he would like the opportunity to address, any
community group, directly about the Homeland Security Site and where things
stand.
I think it would benefit everyone to hear things from the source.

Thanks,


Tom Resek 387-2847