Tuesday, April 03, 2007

Pet owners are making dog and cat food

By DORIE TURNER, Associated Press Writer
11 minutes ago

ATLANTA - Some dog and cat owners frightened by a contamination scare are forsaking the pet-food aisle and grinding up meat in their own kitchens instead.

Sales of pet food recipe books have also shot up since the nationwide pet-food recall began two weeks ago.

Amy Parish, 40, stopped giving her two aging chow chows canned food. Instead, Parish mixes dry food with a mash of chicken, rice, oatmeal and cottage cheese that she prepares twice a week.

"I'm very suspicious of any large-brand manufactured dog food," said Parish, who lives in the Atlanta suburb of Tucker.

But veterinarians warn that making balanced meals for pets can be complicated and should only be a temporary remedy until the scare passes.

Nearly 100 store and major-brand pet foods were recalled by manufacturer Menu Foods Inc. on March 16. Three other companies have recalled some foods since then.

Food and Drug Administration testing found that wheat gluten imported from China was contaminated with a chemical used in the manufacture of plastics. The FDA has confirmed about 15 pet deaths, and anecdotal reports suggest hundreds of cats and dogs may have died.

Some pet owners are not taking any chances.

After Hills Pet Nutrition Inc. recalled one of its cat products, John Slavens, 41, of San Diego, started making homemade food for his two border collies.

He spent five hours in the kitchen Sunday, grinding beef and boiling potatoes and pasta for a week's worth of stew, supplemented with an all-in-one vitamin-mineral powder.

"These dogs are my family," Slavens said.

The FDA and the American Veterinary Medical Association are urging pet owners to switch brands if they are worried. The veterinarian group also warned that many common foods are not safe for pets, including salt, garlic, onions, grapes and chocolate.

Making pet food at home is "kind of like canning: You have to think about bacterial contamination. And how do you make sure it's nutritionally appropriate and balanced for the animal?" said FDA spokeswoman Julie Zawisza. She added: "We wouldn't object. We'd say be knowledgeable about what you need."

On Amazon.com, the cookbook "Real Food for Dogs" moved into the list of top 200 best-sellers this week. Other authors were finding instant success, too.

Dr. Donald Strombeck said the Amazon.com sales rank for his book "Home-Prepared Dog & Cat Diets: The Healthful Alternative" jumped from below 60,000 to about 1,000 after the recalls.

The retired professor of veterinary nutrition at the University of California, Davis, challenged the common assertion that owners should not feed their pets table food.

When he began practicing veterinary medicine in the 1950s, he said, most pet owners fed their pets scraps from the table, keeping the risk of contamination low.

"The pet food industry doesn't want people competing with them," Strombeck said. "An animal can basically eat the same things we eat. They're not going to develop a deficiency."

Robert Van Sickle, co-owner of the Polka Dog Bakery in Boston, said he has received many inquiries from customers on advice for making their own dog food. For his German short-haired pointer, Van Sickle blends carrots, spinach, salmon oil, apple cider vinegar and whatever meat is in his freezer.

"What this scare has shown me is that it's amazing how many people don't know what they are feeding their dogs," he said. "The bright side, for me, as someone interested in animal wellness, is people are asking questions now."
___

Associated Press writers Andrew Bridges in Washington, Jesse Harlan Alderman in Boston, and Marcus Wohlsen in San Francisco contributed to this report.

___
On the Net:

FDA pet food recall information: http://www.fda.gov/oc/opacom/hottopics/petfood.html

(Corrects number of pet deaths to about 15, instead of 15 as stated in previous version, to reflect that the FDA's total is not precise.)

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

In posting this mainstream media article about how pet owners are dealing with the threat to the lives of their companions, True has put out the word that it is not safe to feed pets what you eat yourselves.
Hello? this in the face of mass produced foods that kills our loved ones?
This is just another myth promulgated by the massive pet food industry. What did people and animals do before multi-national corporations put in the right vitamins?
Hmm, when I was young we didn't eat food grown from pesticides. We had stay-at-home moms who knew about nutrition and put up healthful organic foods for us every harvest season. Our mothers knew by instinct what these corporate profiteers can't get right because they are driven by greed.

True North said...

Dear old,
Yes, vets and corporate pet induistry mouthpieces in this MSM article DID say all that stuff about vitamins, etc. and you are correct that they are touting their self-interest.
In choosing to post this story, I wanted to make more information available to those who never thought about making their own pet food.
Of course the MSM will include the opinions of the opposition forces, that is their way. I hope that True readers will see through the BS.
Nonetheless, Old, I thank you for your thoughtful comment and also recall a long-ago youth as well as an early organic foods movement. Just like us people, if our companions are fed a balanced and healthful diet of whole foods, they will meet their nutritional needs. AND they will not be subject to death by poisoning.
True

fastjerry said...

I not trying to be an apologist for the pet food industry or for corporate America, but if we want to be effective with an alternate suggestion we must be sure to be accurate. First, Old suggested corporate greed as the offender, but corporate greed is an important component of success and success means not making mistakes like unsafe additives to the food chain. Making a mistake is perhaps inevitable in any food processing/production and mistakes are very expensive to corporations: they cost the corporate industries significant profits, which in turn flies in the face of the greed claim. In fact, the biggest danger in the large, single source corporate model is that a single mistake affects all the large players like an epidemic, having multiple smaller, more localized sources is the best protection. Biodiversity is probably the most important concept and defense for long term survival, a concept that should be applied equally to all economic production. I suggest revisiting E.F. Schumaker's "Small is Beautiful" .

And, True, making your own "home brew" pet food is hardly a guarantee that one will not poison their pet, judging by the diet choices of middle America we are more likely to be slowly poisoning our animals with excess fats, salts and sugars (yes, even organic) leading to animal obesity on par with with the human condition: balance and diversity, as you suggest, are the most critical elements. I admit to using commercial preparations for all my pets, and all have lived well beyond the norm for their size and species, but I do read labels and am very cautious and intend to check out what the co-op offers in pet foods. Also read this link, good points to consider, I think:http://www.treehugger.com/files/2007/03/tainted_pet_foo.php
Fastjerry

fastjerry said...

Oops, the tail end of the link was cut off, here it is: http//www.
treehugger.com/files/2007/03/
tainted_pet_foo.php